The move means he has held three senior jobs over the last 18 months.
Just over a year ago Cutler, 45, quit his job as Barhale chief executive to join Balfour, replacing Mike Peasland.
He left after nine months in the post amid a wave of restructuring at Balfour.
Dave Sheridan, Group CEO said: “We would like to welcome Mark Cutler to the Keepmoat Group. He has proven expertise in this field and the qualities to compliment our strong executive team.
“I am very much looking forward to working alongside him to continue to drive Keepmoat’s success.”
Keepmoat also announced that James Thomson, chief financial officer since May 2012, has been promoted to the role of deputy chief executive officer.
The management changes come as Keepmoat experiences strong growth.
In the year to September 2014 Keepmoat passed the £1bn turnover milestone and boasts a strengthened balance sheet following the refinance of the business.
Sheridan said that the business following investment by TDR Capital and Sun Capital had significant financial flexibility to drive organic growth, and support any potential acquisition opportunities.