Opinion: Time for change as majors suffer £850m loss

Aaron Morby 9 years ago
Share

There can be little doubt that big name contractors suffered more pain than expected coming out of the last recession.

Seven major contractor businesses have emerged like walking wounded after jointly running up a staggering £850m loss.

Much of this may be down to Balfour Beatty and Vinci, but the extent of the malaise calls in to question the quality of management and risk control processes during the downturn.

Such staggering losses contrast starkly with the volume house builders who are now enjoying a bumper crop of record profits and the help of a Government under intense political pressure to coax them into building more.

Not so magnificent seven Seven of the best house builders
Firm Loss Turnover % loss
on sales
Firm Profit Turnover Profit
margin
Balfour Beatty Constn £391m £6.6bn 6% Barratt £565m £3.8bn 15%
Vinci UK £217m £1bn 22% Berkeley £540m £2.12bn 25%
Sir Robert McAlpine £108m £862m 12.5% Persimmon £475m £2.6bn 18%
Laing O’Rourke Europe £58m £1.7bn 3% Taylor Wimpey £450m £2.7bn 17%
ISG £28m £1.6bn 1.7% Redrow £213m £1.15bn 19%
Morgan Sindall* £27m £1.1bn 2.4% Bellway* £159m £831m 19%
BAM Nuttall £20m £774m 2.6% Bovis £133m £809m 16%
*half-year

The industry is now in a two-speed recovery.

At the front are the country’s leading house builders who have shrugged off their land legacy and debt problems since the 2008/09 housing crash. Two of the best are each serving up stunning pre-tax profits of over £500m a year.

The few publicly-listed volume contractors that doggedly stuck to the traditional and once unfashionable model of running contracting alongside housing businesses are also in good shape to ride the recovery.

And those that can, like Willmott Dixon and Wates, are rolling out more development-led business as a strategy to improve the quality of profits.

In the slower lane, the phrase legacy project is often used to explain away present problems, but this is disguising something more troubling about the past and the future.

Already tight for cash, the recovery is asking big questions of the majors.

They see clients loathe to front-load project payment, Government tightening up on supply chain payment and the rising use of project bank accounts which are all leaving little opportunity to make a living holding onto others cash.

At the same time subcontractor cost inflation shows little sign of abating.

It means the cash flow squeeze is here to stay and it is hard to see better times ahead unless the majors ring the changes.

The brutal fact is the UK business model that sees main contractors take on high project risk for a 1-2% margin is simply not viable any longer.

It must be abandoned for sanity to prevail.

Clients may be moaning about outturn costs on projects now, but they simply are too used to projects being subsidised by loss-making supply chains.

Despite anecdotes that clients are considering stalling the odd marginal scheme, there is still plenty of headroom for a decent profit as a glance at most developers’ accounts testifies.

It would be smart for clients to work much more closely with contractors to understand cash and risk profiles as a starting point.

It would be even smarter for clients to allow main contractors to start pricing building work at a 4% margin.

Then everybody would have a chance to invest in building better and faster.

 

Latest news

Planning Bill to have “seismic” impact on construction

Building-boosting reforms go before Parliament
17 hours ago

Briggs & Forrester hits record revenue and orders

M&E specialist rebounds with strong growth across three divisions
8 minutes ago

Man Utd confirm plan for £2bn ‘super-tent’ stadium

Club to press ahead with 100,000-seat 'Wembley of the North'
21 hours ago

Government spending keeps profits edging-up at Kier

91% of work now with public sector and regulated companies
24 hours ago

Costain on track for step change to 5% margin

Alex Vaughan says order book has jumped £1.5bn to £5.4bn
23 hours ago

Mace tops February contracts league

Confirmation of £300m London Victoria Street project lifts firm to pole position
23 hours ago

Wates raids Laing O’Rourke for new construction operations chief

George Mosey leaves Laing O'Rourke after 16 years
2 days ago

Travis Perkins CEO Pete Redfern steps down due to ill health

Redfern joined builders' merchant last year after 14 years at Taylor Wimpey
2 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins £61m Liverpool lab scheme

Construction to start this Autumn on latest Knowledge Quarter project
23 hours ago

Glencar to build timber-framed office block

Work to start next month on 79,200 sq ft scheme in Maidenhead
2 days ago

Shed specialist Marbank files administration notice

£67m turnover portal-framed building specialist files court notice
2 days ago

Birmingham council submits £1bn Druids Heath plan

High rise estate to be replaced by-3,500 home eco village
2 days ago

Cannabis farm gang posed as utilities contractor

Gang jailed for 28 years after diverting power to more than 100 cannabis farms
4 days ago

Firm fined after workers climb scaffold without ladder

HSE investigation prompted by death on Liverpool site
2 days ago

Clancy renews £250m Southern Water deal

Contractor vows to maximise value for money and minimise disruption
2 days ago

McLaren go-ahead for 314 flats Watford scheme

Police station and magistrates court to be demolished
2 days ago

Former Liverpool mayor charged in building contracts probe

Construction bosses also charged as part of Operation Aloft
5 days ago

Bidding to start for £700m Irish sea interconnector work

Work includes converter stations at Hunterston and Kilroot near Belfast
5 days ago

Muse to redevelop Durham County Hall HQ site

Morgan Sindall regen specialist seals another major development deal
5 days ago

Mace to transform Imperial College Great Hall

Work to start next month on ambitious refit
5 days ago

£100m plan to regenerate former Digbeth ironworks

Hartwell unveils 260,000 sq ft office and 240 homs plan
5 days ago

Legendre UK wins £21m London homes job for Clarion

Tower Hamlets building to be replaced due to building and fire safety issues
5 days ago

Construction buyers report fastest downturn since 2020

Double whammy of decreasing new orders and delayed projects
6 days ago

Bidders day for £15bn schools alliance framework

Online event to set out details of DfE alliancing framework procurement plan
6 days ago

MPs told safety regulator delays forcing industry job cuts

Industry chief warns housing select committee that BSR is now a main block on meeting housing targets
6 days ago

£600m delivery partner named for new hospital programme

Mace/T&T JV named programme delivery partner for £37bn new hospital plan
7 days ago

£230m Southampton waterfront scheme approved

Town Quay includes trio of 25 storey towers around new marina
6 days ago

Planning green light for £10bn Northumberland data centre

Blackstone-backed project will create 1,200 construction jobs
7 days ago

Bauhaus block above Southwark Station gets green light

Student accommodation and affordable housing scheme replaces original office plan
6 days ago

Police arrest plant hire fraud gang

Nine arrests after kit hired "with no intent of ever returning the machines"
7 days ago

Contractor services