Opinion: Time for change as majors suffer £850m loss

Aaron Morby 9 years ago
Share

There can be little doubt that big name contractors suffered more pain than expected coming out of the last recession.

Seven major contractor businesses have emerged like walking wounded after jointly running up a staggering £850m loss.

Much of this may be down to Balfour Beatty and Vinci, but the extent of the malaise calls in to question the quality of management and risk control processes during the downturn.

Such staggering losses contrast starkly with the volume house builders who are now enjoying a bumper crop of record profits and the help of a Government under intense political pressure to coax them into building more.

Not so magnificent seven Seven of the best house builders
Firm Loss Turnover % loss
on sales
Firm Profit Turnover Profit
margin
Balfour Beatty Constn £391m £6.6bn 6% Barratt £565m £3.8bn 15%
Vinci UK £217m £1bn 22% Berkeley £540m £2.12bn 25%
Sir Robert McAlpine £108m £862m 12.5% Persimmon £475m £2.6bn 18%
Laing O’Rourke Europe £58m £1.7bn 3% Taylor Wimpey £450m £2.7bn 17%
ISG £28m £1.6bn 1.7% Redrow £213m £1.15bn 19%
Morgan Sindall* £27m £1.1bn 2.4% Bellway* £159m £831m 19%
BAM Nuttall £20m £774m 2.6% Bovis £133m £809m 16%
*half-year

The industry is now in a two-speed recovery.

At the front are the country’s leading house builders who have shrugged off their land legacy and debt problems since the 2008/09 housing crash. Two of the best are each serving up stunning pre-tax profits of over £500m a year.

The few publicly-listed volume contractors that doggedly stuck to the traditional and once unfashionable model of running contracting alongside housing businesses are also in good shape to ride the recovery.

And those that can, like Willmott Dixon and Wates, are rolling out more development-led business as a strategy to improve the quality of profits.

In the slower lane, the phrase legacy project is often used to explain away present problems, but this is disguising something more troubling about the past and the future.

Already tight for cash, the recovery is asking big questions of the majors.

They see clients loathe to front-load project payment, Government tightening up on supply chain payment and the rising use of project bank accounts which are all leaving little opportunity to make a living holding onto others cash.

At the same time subcontractor cost inflation shows little sign of abating.

It means the cash flow squeeze is here to stay and it is hard to see better times ahead unless the majors ring the changes.

The brutal fact is the UK business model that sees main contractors take on high project risk for a 1-2% margin is simply not viable any longer.

It must be abandoned for sanity to prevail.

Clients may be moaning about outturn costs on projects now, but they simply are too used to projects being subsidised by loss-making supply chains.

Despite anecdotes that clients are considering stalling the odd marginal scheme, there is still plenty of headroom for a decent profit as a glance at most developers’ accounts testifies.

It would be smart for clients to work much more closely with contractors to understand cash and risk profiles as a starting point.

It would be even smarter for clients to allow main contractors to start pricing building work at a 4% margin.

Then everybody would have a chance to invest in building better and faster.

 

Latest news

Keltbray fine increased to £18m after failed bid rigging appeal

Contractor loses penalty discount for settling with competition authorities
17 hours ago

Luxury house builder goes under with 70 job losses

Octagon Developments in administration after 40 years in business
1 day ago

Top Ten best read stories of 2024

The biggest headlines of an eventful year. Have a good one and here's to a successful 2025
1 day ago

BAM Nuttall fined £800,000 after concrete skip tragedy

Young labourer killed by falling bale arm
2 days ago

Keltbray infrastructure business reveals new name

AUREOS means "new dawn" after private equity acquisition
1 day ago

Stiffer fines for over-running street works from next Summer

Cash raised from lane rentals to be channeled into pothole repairs
1 day ago

£113m Basildon rental homes scheme seals build finance

Work expected to start early next year on Market Square project
1 day ago

Notting Hill Genesis seeks more tier 1 repairs contractors

London housing trust seeks eight firms for new £1.5bn repairs framework
1 day ago

Reclaimed steel oil rig columns worked into London office revamp

Curo will use reclaimed bricks and steel for Fitzrovia office overhaul
2 days ago

CITB delays levy approval consultation

Levy agreement talks pushed back by ongoing review into effectiveness of training body
2 days ago

Ofwat approves £104bn water industry spending plan

Household water bills to rise by 36% to fund quadrupling of investment
2 days ago

Costain/ Siemens JV clinches HS2 power supply job

£300m deal for HV power supply systems over the 225km route
2 days ago

Demolition team assembles on Multiplex London Wall site

Erith to start work next month at Deutsche Bank's former headquarters
3 days ago

Norwich Council acts to revive £300m Anglia Square scheme

Council uses Homes England funding to buy stalled site with planning for 1,100 homes
2 days ago

Go-ahead for 4,500-home Cambridgeshire new town

Waterbeach new town plan stalled three years ago after an Environment Agency objection
2 days ago

Henry Boot to take total control of Stonebridge Homes

Deal worth at least £30m
2 days ago

HS2 costs could hit £66bn

Government looking for next estimate to be lower
3 days ago

Mace to close construction logistics arm

Specialist business being wound down
3 days ago

National Grid to invest £35bn over next five years

Plan set out for record investment in electricity transmission infrastructure
3 days ago

Profits double at Barhale

Civils specialist sees order book top £1bn
3 days ago

Balfour wins 68km HV underground power cable deal

Main works to start next year on Eastern Green Link 2 job
3 days ago

Stunning site wrap unveiled on Sloane Street

Hoarding creates illusion of fully formed façade on £53m Galliford Try job
3 days ago

Heathrow Airport upgrade spend takes off again

Airport operator will spend £2.3bn over the next two years
3 days ago

Government buys back over 36,000 military homes

Public ownership deal to release wave of upgrade and new build work
4 days ago

Story Contracting staff braced for rail job losses

Work coming through slower than expected from Network Rail
4 days ago

Ballymore submits two plans for 3,700 East London homes

Construction could start in 2025 on Thames Road and Knights Road schemes
4 days ago

Blackpool council steps in on failed developer’s £300m scheme

Blackpool Central site clearance to start in the New Year as hunt starts for new developer
5 days ago

Brookfield submits retro-first London office plan

Milton Gate plan for Square Mile will hike space by nearly 50%
4 days ago

Bowmer + Kirkland gets start date for £100m Siemens site

Construction to begin early next year on Chippenham scheme
5 days ago

Torsion sells under-construction Leeds BTR scheme

Concrete frame due to start soon on 300-apartment complex
5 days ago

Contractor services