Call for fire tests transparency as 75 buildings fail

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

Industry fire experts are calling for much greater transparency around what type of fire testing regime is being used to check cladding systems.

Cladding is being removed from buildings from Plymouth to Liverpool
Cladding is being removed from buildings from Plymouth to Liverpool

Questions are being raised after the Government revealed the total number of buildings with condemned cladding has soared to 75  – 100% of all those tested.

So far the Government has only confirmed that the Building Research Establishment combustibility test has three categories rated 1 to 3.

It has been judged that cladding material falling in category two or three does not meet the requirements for limited combustibility in Building Regulations, although the details of what this test involves has not been revealed.

Some industry professionals are concerned that the Government has applied the most stringent Building Regulation guidance that only allows materials of limited combustibility or Class A2.

But building elements do not need to comply with A2 grading if fire tests prove the system as a whole meets the requirements to BS8414.

Experts have warned that far more comprehensive tests on the entire cladding system are needed to establish if buildings are at-risk including the insulation and design details such as fire stops.

A cladding contractor and former fireman told the Enquirer: “Nobody knows what the three-stage tests are that they are applying to samples sent in, but all are failing.

“The letter states that the ACM should achieve A2 standard to comply with Building Regs but Approved Document B does not say that. We can’t understand where they are getting their information from.

“It’s highly likely they are failing tower blocks unnecessarily. ”

The shadow housing secretary, John Healey, warned the House of Commons that “cladding is not the whole story”.

Fire risk consultant Stephen Mackenzie said: “The government is fundamentally flawed in its use of the BRE to conduct overly simplistic and limited fire test samples and not the complete cladding assembly.

“The small scale tests on external panels need to to be extended to a full disassembly.”

Another source told the Enquirer: “We are still not being told what materials or systems are failing – is it just Reynobond (PE) cladding or other materials? More information is required.”

In an update on the failed number of cladding samples found on buildings within 26 local areas, Communities Secretary Sajid Javid said the Government was also working with the Government Property Unit to oversee checks on wider public sector buildings.

“Hospitals are well prepared – each one has a tailored fire safety plan,” he said.

“But nothing is more important than the safety of patients and staff, so on a precautionary basis we have asked all hospitals to conduct additional checks.”

Across the wider government estate 15 buildings have been identified as requiring further investigation.

Latest news

Industry’s best construction managers revealed

Full shortlist for CIOB Construction Manager of the Year award
18 hours ago

Government to signal backing for London airports expansion

Chancellor growth plan speech to give nod to Heathrow, Gatwick and Luton plans
16 hours ago

Hospital building plan extended by a decade – full list

All planned projects retained with fresh start dates for industry certainty
24 hours ago

Kier launches £20m share buyback as debt cut

Steady first-half trading shrinks average month end debt to £38m from £137m
23 hours ago

Plans unveiled for £365m Heathrow data centre

Distribution centre developer moves into data centre market
23 hours ago

Plan for 6.5m sq ft Greater Manchester industrial zone

Russell LDP and Harworth to submit ambitious Northern Gateway plan this Spring
23 hours ago

Building boss sold diggers still on HP

Court hears how building director sold rented machines to fund sports car and gambling habit
2 days ago

Wates names new hard FM chief

Jack Prady joins from Thermic Technical FM
2 days ago

Council steps-in at sites where developer failed

First Endeavour LLP went under while building new homes across Fife
2 days ago

Mace confirmed for £93m weather centre HQ

Work to start on weather scientist hub at University of Reading
2 days ago

Council starts £200m hunt to replace Balfour Beatty

Tender race begins after Herefordshire Council parts ways with contractor
2 days ago

St William gets go-ahead for 245-home Stratford scheme

Planning approved for Stratford Gasworks regeneration
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty to sell Omnicom to Hitachi Rail

Digital rail monitoring business employs over 100 engineers
2 days ago

Van Elle partners with Wood on power transmission jobs

Ground investigation and piling deal worth over £30m
2 days ago

Former Balfour regional MD dies before taking up new role

Lindsay McGibbon struck down by cancer
5 days ago

One of Wales’ oldest contractors delivers record profit

Andrew Scott chairman says clients are now looking beyond lowest bids for jobs
5 days ago

Henry administrators chase £10m director payment

Cash frozen as legal action continues
6 days ago

Warning after scammers pose as plant hire bosses

Flannery targeted by fraudsters trying to con customers
5 days ago

Carey co-founder Tom Carey passes away

Contractor confirms death of second of three founding brothers
6 days ago

Robertson and Balfour win £333m schools deal

Contractors land work for five schools in Scotland
5 days ago

Go-ahead for £125m Ealing leisure centre and homes scheme

Council seeks contractor to deliver flagship Gurnell development
5 days ago

State of Englands local roads a ‘national embarrassment’

Spending watchdog urges Govt to tackle £15bn repair backlog
5 days ago

Worker loses three fingers at timber frame factory

Construction supplier fined after panel saw accident
5 days ago

Three in race for £20bn fusion power station

Balfour Beatty, Kier and Ferrovial head consortia in chase for 'star power' reactor
6 days ago

Office work drives 0.4% uptick in construction output

Activity in November grew four times faster than the UK economy as a whole.
6 days ago

Plans in for 34-storey Manchester student tower

Developer Vita plans 861-room tower in First Street district
6 days ago

Council quits homes joint venture to speed-up construction

Worthing Borough Council selling land to Roffey Homes
6 days ago

Kier signs £243m army barracks upgrade

Latest big defence optimisation deal signed off for Aldershot barracks
6 days ago

Winners revealed for £814m FM framework

Latest deal from Pagabo will provide roofing, mechanical and decorating work - see all 27 winners
7 days ago

Jackson signs £19m Sizewell C access roads deal

Latest contract takes work awarded to £2.5bn but concern mounts about final cost
6 days ago

Contractor services