Lendlease ordered to pay £14.8m for city tower falling glass

Aaron Morby 7 years ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Lendlease to payout £14.8m after a London city tower was forced to be reclad for a second time because of falling glass panes on to the street below.

125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding
125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding

The ruling ends a long legal battle surrounding the former London Stock Exchange tower, now known as 125 Old Broad Street, where on one occasion a 15ft plate glass window fell from the 17th floor onto a busy street just missing office workers enjoying an early lunch.

In total 17 plate glass windows failed on the 26-storey tower forcing its owner to pay to reclad the building, just four years after Lendlease had completed its original renovation project.

Lendlease was named throughout the judgement as the defendant.

But the Enquirer understands that was a procedural matter and the case centred on work by glazing contractor Permasteelisa.

A Lendlease spokesperson said: “Permasteelisa and Lendlease have reached an agreement whereby Lendlease will not be financially impacted.”

Klaus Lother, Chief Executive Officer of Permasteelisa UK Ltd said: “This judgment is relevant to an old project executed in 2005 and is connected with a decision by the client to change the project materials.

“The need for changing said materials was attributed by the client to Permasteelisa, which we objected to.

“Although we cannot agree with the conclusions of the judgment, we were long since prepared for such a possibility.

“Therefore it will have no impact on Permasteelisa business in the UK or at Group level.”

Handing down his judgment last week, Mr Justice Stuart-Smith described the project’s failings as “disastrous”.

Lendlease first carried out the extensive redevelopment of 125 Old Broad Street under a two-year design and build contract, completing in 2008.

Between then and 2012, the building suffered 17 spontaneous glazing failures due to nickel sulphide levels in the glass.

Fortunately, no one was seriously injured by falling glass, but the building had to be cloaked in scaffolding to protect the public.

Owners Hammerson, the Bank of Ireland and GE Real Estate then took the decision to pay for the building to be reclad with a new glass curtain walling system in 2013.

The judge said that Lendlease had failed to ensure it had the sufficient documents to prove the glazing supplied had been properly heat-treated to prevent failure.

He said: “I find as a fact that a substantial proportion of the glass that was used on 125 OBS, probably in the region of 35-40% though possibly more, was not heat soaked in accordance with the requirements of the contract.

“If it had all been heat soaked properly, there would probably have been either no breakages or one breakage.”

Around £8.7m of the £14.7m award covers the reglazing cost, with other remedial works and financing charges making up the balance.

Latest news

House builder Camstead goes into administration

Work stopped on three current sites
6 hours ago

Graham wins £100m Cardiff Crossrail phase 1

Work on route to Cardiff Bay to start before end of next year
12 hours ago

Laing O’Rourke appoints new European MD

Peter Lyons to take-up new role in February
1 day ago

Profits dip at Stepnell ahead of demerger

Turnover and secured workloads up ahead of restructure
1 day ago

HS2 green bridge deck takes shape

100m-wide wildlife bridge to carry hedgerows and country lane over HS2
12 hours ago

1,000-home Wolverhampton city centre scheme in for planning

ECF and council advance City Centre West build to rent scheme
1 day ago

Sisk clinches £54m North London council HQ revamp

Haringey's iconic Grade II listed civic centre to be brought back into use
1 day ago

Ofgem approves £2.5bn Eastern Green Link 1

Work to start next Spring on cable project from Scotland to the north of England
1 day ago

Anglian Water hunts for £1bn delivery partner

Programme delivery partner wil integrate with client team over 15-year plan
2 days ago

Hadden collapse costs supply chain £6.7m

"Highly unlikely" subcontractors will receive anything for their unpaid invoices
2 days ago

Management buyout at M&E specialist

£25m turnover Kimpton in second MBO in its 60-year history
2 days ago

BAM finalises £71m deal to replace first major RAAC school

Work to start on new St Leonards Catholic School in Durham
2 days ago

Scaffolder hit by two tonne weight at nuclear plant

Court hands out £633,000 in fines after Dungeness B decommissioning incident
2 days ago

Go-ahead for 860,000 sq ft East London medical campus

Whitechapel Road scheme of six new and repurposed buildings
2 days ago

Site labour rates hit record high as cost inflation returns

Industry's biggest payroll firm says rates rose nearly 5% last month in London
5 days ago

Morris & Spottiswood acquires part of ISG fit-out division

ISG Cathedral acquisition saves 111 jobs and expands presence across England
5 days ago

New work drives Q3 construction output uplift

Third quarter activity up 0.8% despite slowdown in September
5 days ago

Octavius cuts concrete formwork strike time by 5 days

Temperature probes reduce times for safely striking formwork
5 days ago

Plan for 200-home student-led London scheme

Developer Regal is behind new Camden Town scheme
5 days ago

Green light for new £45m tax office in Portsmouth

HMRC to occupy new office complex with construction starting next year
5 days ago

Extra tunnels included in £6bn East West Rail scheme

Government unveils plans for two new tunnels in Cambridgeshire
6 days ago

Infrastructure to get £80bn boost from public sector pensions

New "megafunds" will invest in UK construction projects
6 days ago

Bidders wanted for £800m building safety framework

Fusion21 launches renewal of deal across 12 lots
6 days ago

Winchmore wins £6.5m brickwork package on Stratford flats

Latest award from Graham on £69m development
6 days ago

Motts/Jacobs JV to design £2.5bn West Yorkshire Mass Transit

First construction could begin in 2028
6 days ago

Muse signs landmark deal to redevelop Solihull shopping centre

Mell Square scheme includes 1,600 homes at 6.4ha town centre site
7 days ago

Reds10 raids house builders for two director hires

David Newey and James Bateman join as regional ops directors
7 days ago

Builder killed as telehandler overturns

House builder goes into liquidation before court hearing and £160,000 fine
1 week ago

Balfour Beatty regional MD steps down

Lindsay McGibbon is understood to be exiting for a job in the United States
7 days ago

Firms put on alert for £1.5bn decarbonisation framework

Fusion21 aims to invite bids in January for housing and public buildings retrofit framework
1 week ago

Contractor services