Lendlease ordered to pay £14.8m for city tower falling glass

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Lendlease to payout £14.8m after a London city tower was forced to be reclad for a second time because of falling glass panes on to the street below.

125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding
125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding

The ruling ends a long legal battle surrounding the former London Stock Exchange tower, now known as 125 Old Broad Street, where on one occasion a 15ft plate glass window fell from the 17th floor onto a busy street just missing office workers enjoying an early lunch.

In total 17 plate glass windows failed on the 26-storey tower forcing its owner to pay to reclad the building, just four years after Lendlease had completed its original renovation project.

Lendlease was named throughout the judgement as the defendant.

But the Enquirer understands that was a procedural matter and the case centred on work by glazing contractor Permasteelisa.

A Lendlease spokesperson said: “Permasteelisa and Lendlease have reached an agreement whereby Lendlease will not be financially impacted.”

Klaus Lother, Chief Executive Officer of Permasteelisa UK Ltd said: “This judgment is relevant to an old project executed in 2005 and is connected with a decision by the client to change the project materials.

“The need for changing said materials was attributed by the client to Permasteelisa, which we objected to.

“Although we cannot agree with the conclusions of the judgment, we were long since prepared for such a possibility.

“Therefore it will have no impact on Permasteelisa business in the UK or at Group level.”

Handing down his judgment last week, Mr Justice Stuart-Smith described the project’s failings as “disastrous”.

Lendlease first carried out the extensive redevelopment of 125 Old Broad Street under a two-year design and build contract, completing in 2008.

Between then and 2012, the building suffered 17 spontaneous glazing failures due to nickel sulphide levels in the glass.

Fortunately, no one was seriously injured by falling glass, but the building had to be cloaked in scaffolding to protect the public.

Owners Hammerson, the Bank of Ireland and GE Real Estate then took the decision to pay for the building to be reclad with a new glass curtain walling system in 2013.

The judge said that Lendlease had failed to ensure it had the sufficient documents to prove the glazing supplied had been properly heat-treated to prevent failure.

He said: “I find as a fact that a substantial proportion of the glass that was used on 125 OBS, probably in the region of 35-40% though possibly more, was not heat soaked in accordance with the requirements of the contract.

“If it had all been heat soaked properly, there would probably have been either no breakages or one breakage.”

Around £8.7m of the £14.7m award covers the reglazing cost, with other remedial works and financing charges making up the balance.

Latest news

Cartel watchdog drops probe into cement admixtures

Probe closed as no longer an 'administrative priority'
2 hours ago

Bid race begins for £1bn concrete road replacement deal

National Highways invites bids for Legacy Concrete Roads Reconstruction framework
9 hours ago

Groundworks specialist Kaybridge faces liquidation

£30m turnover contractor has been in business since 1972
10 hours ago

“Cynical” legal bids to block infrastructure neutered

Government backs "builders over blockers" to speed up construction
10 hours ago

Watkin Jones returns to trading profit

Strong ongoing demand for student room supports work pipeline
10 hours ago

Social housing firm Fortem targets £300m turnover

Three-year plan to raise revenue by 50%
10 hours ago

£150m Bristol student scheme approved

B&K tipped for 530-bed Temple Quarter scheme
10 hours ago

Falco electric digger trial could lead to £6m fleet-swap

Utility contractor using new Takeuchi machines on UK Power Networks sites
10 hours ago

Council pulls £274m road scheme over bats row

Ferrovial stood down after £56m spent on Norwich Western Link
1 day ago

£500m house building framework opens for bids

17 firms face fight to retain places on north west housing consortium list
1 day ago

Government faces £49bn estate maintenance backlog

Spending watchdog calls for urgent action to save crumbling public estate
1 day ago

Sellafield awards £95m industrial services framework

Kaeffer seals new access, asbestos and insulation deal
1 day ago

HG Construction names new MD

Greg Purkiss appointment completes corporate restructure
1 day ago

Plasterer in court for Covid loan fraud

Fraudster spent £50,000 Bounce Back loan on gambling, groceries and fantasy football
1 day ago

Industry’s best construction managers revealed

Full shortlist for CIOB Construction Manager of the Year award
2 days ago

Steeplejack dies after 60 metre church fall

Specialist contractor, which has ceased trading since accident, fined £60,000
1 day ago

Government to signal backing for London airports expansion

Chancellor growth plan speech to give nod to Heathrow, Gatwick and Luton plans
2 days ago

Hospital building plan extended by a decade – full list

All planned projects retained with fresh start dates for industry certainty
2 days ago

Kier launches £20m share buyback as debt cut

Steady first-half trading shrinks average month end debt to £38m from £137m
2 days ago

Plans unveiled for £365m Heathrow data centre

Distribution centre developer moves into data centre market
2 days ago

Plan for 6.5m sq ft Greater Manchester industrial zone

Russell LDP and Harworth to submit ambitious Northern Gateway plan this Spring
2 days ago

Building boss sold diggers still on HP

Court hears how building director sold rented machines to fund sports car and gambling habit
3 days ago

Wates names new hard FM chief

Jack Prady joins from Thermic Technical FM
3 days ago

Council steps-in at sites where developer failed

First Endeavour LLP went under while building new homes across Fife
3 days ago

Mace confirmed for £93m weather centre HQ

Work to start on weather scientist hub at University of Reading
3 days ago

Council starts £200m hunt to replace Balfour Beatty

Tender race begins after Herefordshire Council parts ways with contractor
3 days ago

St William gets go-ahead for 245-home Stratford scheme

Planning approved for Stratford Gasworks regeneration
3 days ago

Balfour Beatty to sell Omnicom to Hitachi Rail

Digital rail monitoring business employs over 100 engineers
3 days ago

Van Elle partners with Wood on power transmission jobs

Ground investigation and piling deal worth over £30m
3 days ago

Former Balfour regional MD dies before taking up new role

Lindsay McGibbon struck down by cancer
6 days ago

Contractor services