Lendlease ordered to pay £14.8m for city tower falling glass

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Lendlease to payout £14.8m after a London city tower was forced to be reclad for a second time because of falling glass panes on to the street below.

125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding
125 Old Broad Street after most recent recladding

The ruling ends a long legal battle surrounding the former London Stock Exchange tower, now known as 125 Old Broad Street, where on one occasion a 15ft plate glass window fell from the 17th floor onto a busy street just missing office workers enjoying an early lunch.

In total 17 plate glass windows failed on the 26-storey tower forcing its owner to pay to reclad the building, just four years after Lendlease had completed its original renovation project.

Lendlease was named throughout the judgement as the defendant.

But the Enquirer understands that was a procedural matter and the case centred on work by glazing contractor Permasteelisa.

A Lendlease spokesperson said: “Permasteelisa and Lendlease have reached an agreement whereby Lendlease will not be financially impacted.”

Klaus Lother, Chief Executive Officer of Permasteelisa UK Ltd said: “This judgment is relevant to an old project executed in 2005 and is connected with a decision by the client to change the project materials.

“The need for changing said materials was attributed by the client to Permasteelisa, which we objected to.

“Although we cannot agree with the conclusions of the judgment, we were long since prepared for such a possibility.

“Therefore it will have no impact on Permasteelisa business in the UK or at Group level.”

Handing down his judgment last week, Mr Justice Stuart-Smith described the project’s failings as “disastrous”.

Lendlease first carried out the extensive redevelopment of 125 Old Broad Street under a two-year design and build contract, completing in 2008.

Between then and 2012, the building suffered 17 spontaneous glazing failures due to nickel sulphide levels in the glass.

Fortunately, no one was seriously injured by falling glass, but the building had to be cloaked in scaffolding to protect the public.

Owners Hammerson, the Bank of Ireland and GE Real Estate then took the decision to pay for the building to be reclad with a new glass curtain walling system in 2013.

The judge said that Lendlease had failed to ensure it had the sufficient documents to prove the glazing supplied had been properly heat-treated to prevent failure.

He said: “I find as a fact that a substantial proportion of the glass that was used on 125 OBS, probably in the region of 35-40% though possibly more, was not heat soaked in accordance with the requirements of the contract.

“If it had all been heat soaked properly, there would probably have been either no breakages or one breakage.”

Around £8.7m of the £14.7m award covers the reglazing cost, with other remedial works and financing charges making up the balance.

Latest news

Sweeping changes to public procurement come into force

Procurement Act 2023 brings greater duty to report on contract performance
5 hours ago

£3bn London councils general works deal out to bid

Five-year London Construction Programme framework up for renewal
5 hours ago

Didcot demolition disaster probe enters tenth year

Thames Valley Police "moving towards the latter stages of enquiries"
20 hours ago

Hunt for development partner for £4bn Bristol Temple Quarter

130 ha masterplan could deliver 10,000 new homes
4 hours ago

Sovereign starts hunt for £750m framework builders

Housing association looking for contractors across West, South, London and East
4 hours ago

Bromford sets 11,000 new homes target across West of England

Housing association on land-buying spree to scale-up construction work
5 hours ago

Administrators take control at Acheson Construction

40 staff made redundant at South West regional contractor
3 days ago

34 secure spots on £1bn NEPO civils framework

Balfour Beatty, Graham, Taylor Woodrow and Winvic signed up for first time
3 days ago

Bouygues claims net zero construction goal at Welsh project

Llanelli leisure centre and health campus achieves green construction target
3 days ago

Manchester civil service digital campus approved

Two Government office blocks totaling 900,000sq ft to cost £310m to build
3 days ago

New mobile charging vans crack electric plant downtime anxiety

FM Conway trials new service that recharges small plant in one hour
3 days ago

Build to rent deal kick starts 3,500-home Dagenham scheme

Deal secures 935-home first phase of Ford Dagenham plant redevelopment
4 days ago

RSK adds another 110 staff with N-Able Group deal

Consultant and construction services group makes latest acquisition
3 days ago

JRL Malaysian backers plan 580-home Wheat Quarter scheme

Plans in for Welwyn Garden City Shredded Wheat factory redevelopment
4 days ago

Recycled aggregate firms blast new waste crime levy

10% levy on all recycled aggregate producers to fund policing waste crime
4 days ago

£110m Liverpool Metalworks resi scheme gets nod

Legacie Contracts tipped for 16-storey Pumpfields project
4 days ago

Building products firm fined £1m after double accident

Scaffolder hurt in fall and worker caught in machinery at Norbord factory
4 days ago

Graham lands £42m Woking road upgrade

A320 upgrade will unlock new housing schemes along route
4 days ago

Dandara 300 homes High Wycombe project approved

Firm to demolish Chilterns Shopping Centre for build to rent job
4 days ago

Three Keltbray managers took £600,000 in bribes

Site managers convicted for taking kickbacks from labour supply specialist
5 days ago

Bidding starts for £1bn YORcivil major works deal

Eight firms face fight to renew places on big civils framework
5 days ago

ECF clinches deal for Hull 850-home urban village

East Bank waterside village plan advances
6 days ago

Maintenance firm Cardo in second Scottish acquisition

North Lanarkshire property maintenance firm Rodgers & Johnston bought
5 days ago

Kier confirms £41m Salford Uni health building job

Work starts on specialist three storey teaching building
5 days ago

Passenger train derailed after hitting track left by Colas workers

Contractor and Network Rail asked to make improvements after accident
6 days ago

Bryson signs £6m safety products deal with Skanska

Safety specialist becomes sole supplier to contracting giant
6 days ago

Murphy wins St Fergus gas compressor project

Three low emission compressor units to be installed for National Gas
6 days ago

Blenheim House payout hopes fade as claims hit £33m

Suggested 10p in the £1 payout for subcontractors now unlikely
6 days ago

£1.3bn decarbonising and fire safety deals out for bid

South East Consortium starts hunt for firms for housing upgrade work prize
6 days ago

£30m turnover M&E contractor files administration notice

TNA Electrical makes administration application
6 days ago

Contractor services