Opinion: Time to fight poor payment practice

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

Carillion has managed to divide the subcontracting world with its so-called Early Payment Facility for the supply chain. 

Hundreds of firms working for Carillion have happily signed up to the new 120-day terms which allow earlier payment for a small fee.

They believe the reverse factoring agreement, based on the extended payment terms, is a small price to pay for the right to draw down payments at 45 days.

Carillion’s promise to reimburse the fee banks charge suppliers for the privilege of drawing down cash early has proved a more effective sweetener than many would have first thought. Of course, it remains to be seen how long this offer will last.

The rest of the industry sees the new terms as an attack on the 30-day payment or less that Government wants to see in private and public sector project supply chains.

What the heated payment debate has highlighted is the depths to which industry payment practices have sunk.

Subcontractors now appear willing to accept anything that will speed-up the flow of cash owed to them.

Predictably other main contractors now plan to follow suit although all are going to great pains to emphasise the fact that their payment terms are not being extended.

Reverse factoring will bring relief to some cash-strapped specialists in the short term. What it cannot be allowed to become is an alternative to paying firms promptly.

Whatever the good intentions, it is a fundamentally flawed and morally bankrupt approach.

Many subcontractors are struggling to live with the invidious main contractor rebate on money they are owed.

Paying an extra fee for the right to be paid earlier means many will find themselves 3-4% down in cash off sales.

This is a world away from the fine words and payment charters that Government believes are taking root in the supply chain.

What lies at the heart of the present problem is a major cash squeeze among main contractors.

Falling orders, the growth in term contracts that are far less attractive in cash flow terms and the advance of project bank accounts are all taking their toll on cash reserves.

The main contractor cash crunch will only get worse going forward.

Upward pressure already being felt on labour and material prices is sure to intensify in coming months and strike hard next year.

As order levels improve good subcontractors will find themselves in a much stronger bargaining position.

It may still be early in the recovery but subcontractors may soon be turning the tables on main contractors.

Latest news

Morgan Sindall starts £90m Cambridge mixed-use job

Works starts on Mill Yard regeneration scheme two years after planning go-ahead
9 mins ago

Cardo breaks into Scotland with fifth acquisition

Investor-backed building maintenance contractor
8 mins ago

Tilbury Douglas bags major Barbican Centre M&E upgrade

Barbican Arts Centre revamp could be worth up to £185m over 10 years
7 mins ago

Former Keltbray site managers stand trial over contract “bribes”

Trio accused of taking kickbacks from labour supply specialist
1 day ago

Trio of tech giants unveil £14bn AI data centre hub building plans

Building bonanza beckons as total committed investment hits £39bn
24 hours ago

Crest Nicholson delays results over £250m fire safety provision

Auditors request more time to confirm figures
24 hours ago

Bid race for £55m London leisure centre and homes

Tower Hamlets advances St George's swimming pool and 29 homes plan
23 hours ago

Winners revealed as NHS plans to spend £500m on decarbonisation

Refurb deal will help NHS become world’s first net zero national health service
2 days ago

Seven scoop £850m Yorkshire Water complex projects deal

Firms will deliver non-infrastructure clean and wastewater assets over the next five years
2 days ago

L&G submits plan for £350m Bristol Temple Island

520 homes, two office blocks and hotel plan for former diesel depot site
2 days ago

London Embankment scheme rebooted as student rooms

Urbanest plans Albert Embankment student towers
2 days ago

Hercules tops £100m turnover but suffers £1.7m loss

Suction excavator arm drags labour supply agency into the red
2 days ago

£22m Leicester station revamp rethink after one bid

Council to retender London Road station refurbishment
2 days ago

Watchdog extends competition probe into house builders

Competition and Markets Authority to gather more evidence
2 days ago

Universal Civils and Build picks-up another ISG job

Contractor to complete Wilson Sports Village in Clayton-le-Moors
5 days ago

Precast worker loses leg after 800kg pallet drop

Sheffield manufacturer fined £60,000 after accident
2 days ago

Prep work starts for vast HS2 box slide under A46

Freyssinet designed system will push 14,500t box under Kenilworth Bypass
6 days ago

Downing Construction hit by third year of losses

Building safety works and problem student job tip Liverpool builder £5.8m into red
5 days ago

Problem contracts make it another tricky year for Taziker

Infrastructure specialist confident restructure and new strategy now paying off
5 days ago

£250m Stockport homes scheme set to start

Oak Construction to deliver first block in 440-flats scheme
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins Canary Wharf office-to-labs job

Construction to start this month on £65m conversion
6 days ago

Building stone firm ignores silica dust safety warnings

Workers at risk after manufacturer ignores HSE improvement notices
5 days ago

Resi developer Sheen Lane heading for administration

Richmond based firm has a turnover of £50m
6 days ago

Building safety act adding six months to delivery times

New approval gateways slow student room development programmes
6 days ago

Five contractors win £550m airfield framework deal

MAG picks team for Manchester, Stansted and East Midlands airports
6 days ago

Galldris bounces back to strong profits

South east civils specialist gets trading margin up to 11%
6 days ago

Management buyout at Midlands contractor

Family business GI Sykes sold to management
6 days ago

Taylor Woodrow wins Wolverhampton city centre revamp

£19m contract will last two-and-a-half years
6 days ago

Morgan Sindall contracts league champion for second year

Kier ranks second in closely contested race between majors
7 days ago

New Year layoffs as Scottish modular house builder collapses

East Ayrshire Connect Modular falls into administration
7 days ago

Contractor services