Construction disputes hit record level

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

The level of construction disputes has risen to an all time high, with a third of joint ventures ending in a row over contract terms.

Research carried of by cost consultant E C Harris reveals that the most common causes of disputes it handles relate to omissions and errors in the original contract documents.

But greater use of adjudication has seen the average time taken to resolve a dispute shorten to 7.9 months from 12.9 months in 2012.

In the UK, EC Harris has seen a steady rise in the total value of claims it advises on.

Four years ago this stood at just £4.5m, but it rose sharply to £16m in 2012 and £16.5m in 2013.

The recent upturn in market conditions and claims by employers for alleged defective works are two of the key drivers causing disputes.

The more buoyant market means that contractors are more prepared to take action to recover losses that they may have suffered by entering into contracts over the last five years when there was a sharp downward pressure on tender prices.

This has also led to a number of speculative claims being submitted, most now citing the landmark Walter Lilly case on work delays, which has been seen as a panacea for all ills.

Gary Kitt, UK Head of Contract Solutions at EC Harris, said: “The report reflects the scale of the increasing pressures on the construction industry of a reticence to invest in the skills and training required to implement and understand a clear procurement and construction strategy.

“With pressures to start and finish projects on time and on budget, we are also likely to see increased pressures at the end of the project as disputes are lodged.

He added: “By investing in time and resources at the outset, clients have the opportunity to reduce the spend on dispute resolution by as much as tenfold.”

Top five causes of disputes last year

  1. Errors and/ or omissions in the contract document
  2. Failure to make interim awards on extensions of time and compensation
  3. Differing site conditions
  4. Incomplete design information or Employer requirements (for D&B/D&C)
  5. A failure to properly administer the contract

Ranked in descending order

Kitt added: “The UK’s unique adjudication process has enabled it to set itself apart from its global peers, resulting in a reduction of time for resolution of disputes.

Adjudication is preferred over costly litigation, which requires a period of at least three months to go through the pre-action stages and even longer to resolve.

“As the market improves, more companies are looking to go through the shorter and less in-depth adjudication route, leading to temporarily binding decisions that are only rarely challenged in the Courts.”

Latest news

Staff stunned as engineering consultancy Clarkebond closes

Firm was only bought three months ago by rival Independent Design House Group
4 days ago

Vistry issues third profit warning in three months

Profit expected to fall £50m below forecast due to delayed completions
4 days ago

Miller Homes buys St Modwen Homes for £215m

Scottish house builder snaps up £368m turnover rival
7 days ago

Keltbray fine increased to £18m after failed bid rigging appeal

Contractor loses penalty discount for settling with competition authorities
1 week ago

Luxury house builder goes under with 70 job losses

Octagon Developments in administration after 40 years in business
1 week ago

Top Ten best read stories of 2024

The biggest headlines of an eventful year. Have a good one and here's to a successful 2025
1 week ago

BAM Nuttall fined £800,000 after concrete skip tragedy

Young labourer killed by falling bale arm
1 week ago

Keltbray infrastructure business reveals new name

AUREOS means "new dawn" after private equity acquisition
1 week ago

Stiffer fines for over-running street works from next Summer

Cash raised from lane rentals to be channeled into pothole repairs
1 week ago

£113m Basildon rental homes scheme seals build finance

Work expected to start early next year on Market Square project
1 week ago

Notting Hill Genesis seeks more tier 1 repairs contractors

London housing trust seeks eight firms for new £1.5bn repairs framework
1 week ago

Reclaimed steel oil rig columns worked into London office revamp

Curo will use reclaimed bricks and steel for Fitzrovia office overhaul
1 week ago

CITB delays levy approval consultation

Levy agreement talks pushed back by ongoing review into effectiveness of training body
1 week ago

Ofwat approves £104bn water industry spending plan

Household water bills to rise by 36% to fund quadrupling of investment
1 week ago

Costain/ Siemens JV clinches HS2 power supply job

£300m deal for HV power supply systems over the 225km route
1 week ago

Demolition team assembles on Multiplex London Wall site

Erith to start work next month at Deutsche Bank's former headquarters
1 week ago

Norwich Council acts to revive £300m Anglia Square scheme

Council uses Homes England funding to buy stalled site with planning for 1,100 homes
1 week ago

Go-ahead for 4,500-home Cambridgeshire new town

Waterbeach new town plan stalled three years ago after an Environment Agency objection
1 week ago

Henry Boot to take total control of Stonebridge Homes

Deal worth at least £30m
1 week ago

HS2 costs could hit £66bn

Government looking for next estimate to be lower
1 week ago

Mace to close construction logistics arm

Specialist business being wound down
1 week ago

National Grid to invest £35bn over next five years

Plan set out for record investment in electricity transmission infrastructure
1 week ago

Profits double at Barhale

Civils specialist sees order book top £1bn
1 week ago

Balfour wins 68km HV underground power cable deal

Main works to start next year on Eastern Green Link 2 job
1 week ago

Stunning site wrap unveiled on Sloane Street

Hoarding creates illusion of fully formed façade on £53m Galliford Try job
1 week ago

Heathrow Airport upgrade spend takes off again

Airport operator will spend £2.3bn over the next two years
1 week ago

Government buys back over 36,000 military homes

Public ownership deal to release wave of upgrade and new build work
2 weeks ago

Story Contracting staff braced for rail job losses

Work coming through slower than expected from Network Rail
2 weeks ago

Ballymore submits two plans for 3,700 East London homes

Construction could start in 2025 on Thames Road and Knights Road schemes
2 weeks ago

Blackpool council steps in on failed developer’s £300m scheme

Blackpool Central site clearance to start in the New Year as hunt starts for new developer
2 weeks ago

Contractor services