True cost of cladding crisis as high as £50bn

Aaron Morby 4 years ago
Share

The true cost of the national fire safety recladding project is 10 times higher than the Government’s allocated funding, according to one of the largest specialist contractors in the Midlands.

The government has set aside £5bn for cladding remediation works but this falls woefully short of the £50bn estimate Colmore Tang Construction believes is needed to make every high-rise housing development compliant.

The firm, which set up a specialist cladding arm at the start of this year, has priced remedial projects on over 20 typical developments in Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester.

It found the average cost of these works to be around £4.65m for buildings above 18m and £2m for buildings between 11m and 18m, which they claim is fair reflection of typical costs across the country.

According to Government figures around 5,000 buildings over 18m require an EWS1 certificate and may require remedial works, while around 35,000 11-18m buildings also fall into this category.

According to Colmore Tang’s pricing, which reflects their first-hand remedial works pricing experiance, this would bring the total to around £25bn for buildings over 18m and £70bn for buildings between 11m and 18m.

Given the paucity of information generally available and taking an optimistic view, they have reduced the theoretical total of £95bn by around half for safe measure, arriving at almost £50bn + VAT  as a realistic upper sum.

There has been mounting pressure from MPs to reassess the size of the Building Safety Fund, with the Housing, Communities and Local Government committee claiming the full cost of remedial works could be closer to £15bn.

The firm warns that some professionals have submitted budgets that are as much as three to four times below the real cost of the works.

It said that a developer in Birmingham submitted a bid for £3m despite the full project being worth closer to £10m, and claims it is a phenomenon being repeated across the country.

Steve Underwood, Chief Operating Officer of Colmore Tang, said: “The bottom line is that the true cost of remedial works has been severely underestimated and meaningful progress won’t be made until politicians and industry professionals develop a clearer understanding of funding and logistical challenges at hand here.

“Our estimates are not plucked out of thin air but are based upon real life scenarios which we see day in, day out. There’s a stark difference between costing a project and actually executing it, which largely explains this discrepancy.

“We’re seeing developers and surveyors quoting budgets that are nowhere near where they should be and we’re sleep walking into a scenario in which that only becomes apparent half way through the remedial works. That’s bad news for everyone.

“Suggestions that by simply re-tendering schemes we can reduce costs to original figures are patently unrealistic and quite frankly, dangerous.

“The race to the bottom approach to costing produced the poor workmanship, material standards and quality control which led to the cladding crisis in the first place and we are in danger of things spiralling out of control if we don’t buck up our ideas,” he warned.

 

Latest news

Bidders day for £15bn schools alliance framework

Online event to set out details of DfE alliancing framework procurement plan
2 hours ago

MPs told safety regulator delays forcing industry job cuts

Industry chief warns housing select committee that BSR is now a main block on meeting housing targets
2 hours ago

£600m delivery partner named for new hospital programme

Mace/T&T JV named programme delivery partner for £37bn new hospital plan
16 hours ago

£230m Southampton waterfront scheme approved

Town Quay includes trio of 25 storey towers around new marina
2 hours ago

Planning green light for £10bn Northumberland data centre

Blackstone-backed project will create 1,200 construction jobs
20 hours ago

Bauhaus block above Southwark Station gets green light

Student accommodation and affordable housing scheme replaces original office plan
2 hours ago

Police arrest plant hire fraud gang

Nine arrests after kit hired "with no intent of ever returning the machines"
23 hours ago

Balfour Beatty boss Leo Quinn to step down

Group Chief Executive to be replaced by consultant AtkinsRéalis chief Philip Hoare
1 day ago

Galliford Try upgrades target as half-year profits jump 54%

Firm closes in on deal to take on ISG custodial work
1 day ago

Trespasser dies in crane fall at Willmott Dixon site

Tragedy after man breaks into £60m Manchester science park site
1 day ago

Ibstock pulls out of GRC cladding market

Materials giant blames subcontractor failures and low margins
1 day ago

Green light for 1,000-home Wolverhampton city centre regen

Phase one of ECF Smithgate scheme to start this year
1 day ago

Oval revises Manchester scheme with trio of towers

Flats doubled to 800 at reworked Albert Bridge House project
1 day ago

More repair work needed at McAlpine problem panel hotel

Contractor looking for long-term solution to loose panels
1 day ago

Redesign delays hit giant McAlpine car battery factory

Size of first building reduced and steelwork start pushed back
2 days ago

‘Affordable’ HS2 Crewe to Euston plan submitted to Treasury

Industry presses for scaled back Euston terminus and connection to Crewe
2 days ago

Regal submits plan to revive stalled London resi tower

Swiss Cottage project redesigned with second staircase and 237 flats
2 days ago

Construction boss jailed for siphoning off cash for casino

Money removed from contracting firms before they went under
3 days ago

Muse signs up to £3.2bn Solihull health campus district

Ambitious Arden Cross scheme next to HS2 Interchange advances
2 days ago

Drees & Sommer acquires RSP Consulting Engineers

Expanding consultant sees UK workforce grow to 300
2 days ago

Watkin Jones wins over £50m student digs campus upgrade

Work to start next month on phase 714-bed south London campus
3 days ago

Severfield warns on profits blaming major project delays

Steelwork firm cancels share buyback and steps up cost cutting programme
3 days ago

Administrators go in at aggregates firm Ashville

Administrators from Leonard Curtis now in charge of London based aggregates specialist
4 days ago

Costain start date for £67m Romford flyover replacement

Work to start this summer on Gallows Corner bridge rebuild
3 days ago

North West regional civils contractor in administration

Colin Briscoe Construction employed 25 staff
3 days ago

Work starts on tyres to jet fuel recycling plant

£100m Sunderland plant will produce around 30,000t of liquid fuel
3 days ago

Kier targets £400m of logistics work with Investec JV

Hemel Hempstead site marks start of new venture
3 days ago

Watchdog MPs raise alarm over HS2 Euston station plan

Public spending watchdog red flags 'no plan or timescale' for London Terminus
6 days ago

Network Rail fined £3.41m after Surbiton track worker death

30-year-old track worker Tyler Byrne was struck by a passenger train in Surbiton
7 days ago

Government picks 43 consultants for Net Zero programmes

Jacobs, Mace, Mott MacDonald and Costain feature across multiple lots
6 days ago

Contractor services