Pimlico Plumbers holiday pay ruling could trigger wave of claims

Aaron Morby 3 years ago
Share

Contractors are being warned to clarify the status of self-employed subbies following a landmark supreme court ruling that saw a Pimlico Plumbers worker win a claim for £74,000 in holiday back pay.

In a long-running legal battle, heating engineer Gary Smith, who worked for the company between 2005 and 2011, claimed he was owed holiday pay by Pimlico after the Supreme Court had previously ruled separately that he was a worker and not self-employed.

In his subsequent case that followed on from the employment status ruling, Smith’s claim for backdated holiday pay was at first rejected by an employment appeal tribunal on the grounds that he had not filed his claim quickly enough.

Under tribunal rules, Smith should have made his claim for missed pay within three months of each holiday period, dating back to 2005.

But the Court of Appeal has now overturned the lower courts’ judgments in a landmark decision this month that will have far-reaching impacts across the industry.

It held that ‘a worker can only lose this right if the employer can specifically and transparently show that they gave the worker the opportunity to take paid annual leave, encouraged the worker to take paid annual leave and informed the worker that the right would be lost at the end of the year.’

This means that ‘if the employer cannot evidence this, then the right does not lapse at the end of the year, it carries over and accumulates until termination of the contract.’

The ruling has prompted several industry trade bodies to write to its member contractors.

The Electrical Contractors Association warned members the ruling was important to all employers who deny workers the right to paid annual leave, usually on the basis that they are ‘self-employed.’

It reminded firms of the importance of correctly determining employment status and implementing the applicable rights that status confers.

The industry’s largest payer of subcontractors, Hudson Contract, said the ruling upped the ante but added it all hinged on ensuring the correct employment status.

Ian Anfield, managing director of Hudson Contract, said that it was important to remember that not all subbies are automatically ‘workers’.

He said: “The key fact in the Smith v Pimlico Plumbers case was that very early on an Employment Tribunal found Smith was a ‘worker’ – without that ruling the latest simply would not have happened.

“However, the bigger picture is that many users of subbies will be at risk.

“We have seen an explosion of so-called commercial contractors and employment agencies setting up CIS payroll companies to generate cash.

“The vast majority cut corners and wouldn’t have the funds or the knowledge to deal with complex cases.

“This places their clients at huge risk so there could be thousands of subbies out there eyeing Pimlico-type claims. If the economy turns and things tighten up we can expect to see lots of these cases go to court.

“During the last recession, before most of our competitors even existed, we fended off a number of spurious worker claims and our experience goes back even further than that.

“The question for contractors going forward is whether their current arrangements are watertight and can stand up to scrutiny.

“There’s no doubt this ruling by the Court of Appeal has upped the ante by increasing financial liabilities if a status case is lost, so it must be time to re-examine and scrutinise the credibility of what payroll companies claim they bring to the table.”

 

Latest news

Final phase of £1.5bn Elephant and Castle revamp hits planning

Get Living submits revised plan for 500 homes and 450-bed student block
19 hours ago

Aston Villa to revamp North Stand

Club to reuse existing structure rather than complete rebuild
18 hours ago

Sir Robert McAlpine claws way back into profit

Firm says return to profit and strong cash balance validates new strategy
22 hours ago

Severfield to cut staff by 6% amid pricing pressure

Steelwork contractor warns of extended tighter pricing due to project delays
23 hours ago

JRL completes sale of 50% stake to Malaysian giant IJM

Deal boosts balance sheet and kicks starts growth plan
23 hours ago

Green light for £100m Liverpool Baltic station build

Enabling highway works to start in the autumn
2 days ago

First live tests for flying construction robots

Drones can lay construction materials at height on site
23 hours ago

Three firms land £170m Gentoo Sunderland housing deal

PHS Solutions, Esh and RE:GEN to deliver 10-year home upgrade plan
2 days ago

Gateway gridlock hits build-to-rent delivery as starts nosedive

Build to rent starts plunge 18% in the capital
2 days ago

Call to shift Gateway 2 checks to end building bottleneck

"The current system isn't working but we all want to see safe buildings"
2 days ago

GBN launches £600m bid race for SMR engineer roles

Owner engineers to provide technical and assurance services
2 days ago

Wates hires ex-Homes England chief to head public sector push

Robert Stone to spearhead its public sector and national frameworks strategy
2 days ago

Acheson Construction collapse costs suppliers £8.5m

One frustrated creditor seized a telehandler after contractor went into administration
3 days ago

Dominus wins go-ahead for 173-bed Glasgow scheme

Old Wynd Street job expected to cost around £25m to build
3 days ago

Safety Regulator misses deadline to clear Gateway 2 backlog

Investors pulling out of funding high rise buildings
3 days ago

CITB still sitting on £95m cash pile

Staff numbers jump from 666 to 763 as training body wage bill soars
3 days ago

£500m road surfacing framework market call

NEPO goes out to consultation on north east regional highways deal
3 days ago

Two share £220m Scottish rail repairs and minor works deal

AmcoGiffen and CPMS win civils and building repair deals
3 days ago

Builder wanted for £60m London leisure and flats job

Tower Hamlets aims to replace St George’s Leisure Centre in Shadwell
3 days ago

Contractor confirmed for business park expansion

Roe Developments to start on next phase of Castle Donington scheme
3 days ago

Driver escapes injury as scaffold collapses onto van

Major three-lift scaffold fall blocks north London high street
1 week ago

Gilbert Ash to be sold to staff

£267m turnover contractor to transition to an Employee Ownership Trust
1 week ago

M Group seals biggest-ever deal with Telent takeover

Digital infrastructure specialist deal lifts turnover to £3bn
1 week ago

Aggregates firm Ashville went down owing more than £3m

Debts revealed in Companies House update
1 week ago

Cardo saves 100 jobs at Breyer roofing arm

Private equity-backed Welsh maintenance group continues to expand
1 week ago

Excavator knocked off lorry going under bridge

Traffic Commissioner inquiry after accident in south London
1 week ago

Czech energy tycoon buys UK’s biggest rebar supplier

Spanish offload Celsa UK operation to be rebranded 7 Steel UK
1 week ago

Caddick Construction targets £400m turnover

Regional shake-up pays off at contracting arm
1 week ago

Redrow chief steps down after Barratt merger

Matthew Pratt leaving after 22 years
1 week ago

United Living names new property services senior team

New CEO and COO appointed to lead growth in housing upkeep and retrofit
1 week ago

Contractor services