Watchdog MPs raise alarm over HS2 Euston station plan

Aaron Morby 1 month ago
Share

MPs on the Public Accounts Committee have lambasted the management of the HS2 project and raised grave concerns about the latest plan to deliver the Euston terminus in London.

Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built
Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built

Their report published today calls for “fundamental reset” of the project by the summer.

They warn that they remain sceptical about the Government’s ability to successfully deliver its revised programme following a litany of failures and unheeded warnings.

The report says that the HS2 programme has become a casebook example of how not to run a major project.

“It is unacceptable that over a decade into the programme we still do not know what it will cost, what the final scope will be, when it will finally be completed or what benefits it will deliver,” states their report.

Watchdog MPs also highlighted the significant challenges facing plans to build the Euston Station terminus using a third party development body.

As plans stand, HS2 will open with a terminus at Old Old Common. Despite plans to launch the TBM tunnel drive next year to Euston from Old Oak Common there are no detailed plans or timescale for delivering the Euston Terminus, warns the report.

The Government’s Euston plans currently rest on the £6bn cost being significantly underpinned by the private sector.

The PAC said it was concerned that there is no clear plan for this, and said it was sceptical the private sector would come forward to the level required.

The government confirmed that HS2 would terminate at London Euston in the Autumn 2024 budget.

However, the PAC warns the Department still does not yet have a plan for the work at Euston which includes: the HS2 station, the existing Network Rail station, the underground station, and the commercial and housing developments near the station.

“In addition, the Department intends the work to be sustantively privately funded, but it is unclear how achievable this goal is,” they warn.

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP, Chair of the Committee, said: “Our Committee has not made recommendations in our report on delivering better outcomes for HS2’s future passengers.

“We are long past that point. It is time to deal with HS2 as what it is – a cautionary tale that should be studied by future Governments in how not to run a major project.

“We are sceptical of Government’s ability to successfully deliver even a curtailed scheme, one which we already know will on its face bring very poor value for money. The question has instead become: what possible benefit can the Government now salvage for the taxpayer, from a mess that presents real risks to the UK’s overall reputation?”

The Department for Transport’s present cost estimated set out in November 2023 is £45bn to £54bn compared with HS2 Ltd’s latest estimate of £54bn to £66bn in June 2024.

Both cost estimates are still in 2019 prices, once adjusted for inflation, the total programme costs might be close to £80bn, states the report.

 

Latest news

Deck falls off huge scissor lift at Winvic site

Two men seriously injured as platform plunges to the ground
2 days ago

Bouygues seals deal for £119m Cardiff college campus

Construction to start in June on two new buildings
3 days ago

Bid race starts for £15bn schools framework refresh

DfE throws framework open to more contractors
3 days ago

Berkeley’s £600m Borough Triangle project approved

Controversial scheme features two towers of 38 and 44-storeys
3 days ago

London Mayor calls in blocked 600-bed student scheme

Refused 20-storey London PBSA block may still be built
3 days ago

HG to build 500-bed London Stratford student scheme

Work will start later this year subject to gateway 2 safety approval
3 days ago

Arrest after pedestrian death on construction site

Tragedy during site preparation works for new Wigan car park
3 days ago

British Steel threatens closure of Scunthorpe blast furnaces

Chinese owners say sectional steel and rail supplies will be maintained
4 days ago

Planning green light for Sheffield warehouse site

Existing factories to be demolished in new scheme for Rula Developments
3 days ago

New rail property company to unlock land for 40,000 homes

First four sites released in Newcastle, Cambridge, Manchester, and Nottingham
4 days ago

Drainage specialist Subscan files administration notice

Specialist employing 131 people files court notice
4 days ago

Four win Network Rail £300m engineering design deal

Eastern region deal will include design for Northern Powerhouse Rail
4 days ago

Funding go-ahead for Banwell bypass after fresh cost hike

Galliford Try contract rises £14m to £64m after final design change
4 days ago

Graham wins Southport £75m Marine Lakes Centre

Firm replaces Kier which parted ways with backer Sefton Council
4 days ago

Chancellor unveils extra £2bn capital spend a year

Construction promised a defence dividend in military base and homes upgrade work
5 days ago

McLaren confirms subcontractor team on £135m warehouse job

Work starts on TN2 Gateway site in Kent.
5 days ago

Vistry profits slump after site costs reporting debacle

House builder launches internal whistle-blowing service in business culture review
5 days ago

Severfield chief to step down

Alan Dunsmore to leave structural steel group by end of June
5 days ago

Funding hurdle remains as Lower Thames Crossing gains consent

Government claims £9bn project may start in 2026 as private finance options explored
6 days ago

Mace wins £600m Euston Tower overhaul

1970s tower's foundations and core to be retained as floor plates extended
5 days ago

Summer start for main works on London green tower

Axa sanctions start at 50 Fenchurch Street 36-storey office block
5 days ago

Japan’s leading flats builder JVs with L&G for UK push

Partners plan to build over 1,000 rental homes in London
5 days ago

Wates submits plan for 1,000 homes Harrow council scheme

Former civic centre Poets' Corner site kicks off housing partnership
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall upgrades forecast for next 12 months

Overbury fit-out arm gets off to a flying start in 2025
6 days ago

Restructure underway at Henry Boot Construction

New management team restructures business after drop in turnover
6 days ago

Government pledges £2bn stop-gap funding for 18,000 homes

Funding avoids cliff-edge in social housing delivery before new grant programme agreed
6 days ago

Just two major new roads schemes to start this year

National Highways sets out one-year interim spending plan after RIS3 delay
6 days ago

Plans go in for £400m GRAHAM Manchester site

Demolition and enabling works underway with main construction set to start next year
6 days ago

Building safety levy rate set at up to £10,000 a home in London

Levy introduction pushed back a year to Autumn 2026 - list of new rates
7 days ago

BAM wins £100m revamp of Broadgate Tower in London

Front of tower 3-storey extension to use cross laminate time and re-used steel
7 days ago

Contractor services