MPs call to stall £450m PFI Liverpool hospital job

Aaron Morby 14 years ago
Share

Powerful spending watchdog MPs have called on the Government to stall the planned £450m Liverpool Hospital project for a line by line review of value for money.

The Commons Treasury Committee has launched a stinging attack on the private finance initiative and claimed it offered taxpayers poor value for money.

The Committee report published yesterday warned the long-term costs of PFI deals were now significantly higher than conventional Government borrowing and it urged ministers to use them “as sparingly as possible” until new rules are in place.

“We ask the government to give further consideration before proceeding with the procurement, in its present form, of the Royal Liverpool and Broadgreen Hospital,” says the report.

The call is a serious blow to Carillion and Interserve, which last month were named as the two final bidders for the contract to build the Royal Liverpool.

MPs said that higher borrowing costs since the credit crisis meant PFI projects were an “extremely inefficient” method of financing.

According to the report, the average cost of capital for a PFI project is more than 8%, double the long term government bond rate.

They concluded that this extra cost was not being offset by savings and benefits in other areas of PFI projects.

Due to the financing costs involved, it said paying off a £1bn debt incurred through PFI cost the taxpayer equivalent to a direct government debt of £1.7bn.

The Treasury will respond to the MPs’ report by around October.

The CBI said the government needed to decide how PFI would develop in the future as investors needed certainty and the economy badly needed private investment.

“With the state of the public finances, it is absolutely essential we attract the billions of pounds of private finance needed to upgrade our national infrastructure and boost jobs and growth,” said its deputy director general Neil Bentley.
“To do this, investors need confidence, and the Government must decide sooner rather than later how PFI will evolve, alongside a range of alternatives, such as Tax Increment Funding and Pension Fund Financing.
He added: “It’s worth remembering that without PFI we would not have seen hundreds of much-needed hospitals, schools and homes delivered on time and within budget.”

Latest news

Mace confirmed for £140m Gatwick Airport Pier 6 extension

Contractor PJ Hegarty has started enabling works in middle of busy airport
15 hours ago

Graham takes on ISG £45m Coventry cultural hub job

Firm will start conversion work in the Spring on former IKEA store
16 hours ago

Alun Griffiths to “restructure and resize” after £95m loss

Redundancies due to be announced at Welsh civils contractor
2 days ago

Fire safety project approval delays hit Van Elle profits

Piling specialist also reviews future of Canadian operation amid fresh economic uncertainty
23 hours ago

JRL Malaysian backers plan £150m London city office refurb

Ardmore set to deliver landmark 25 Finsbury Circus building overhaul
22 hours ago

500-home block to replace 19 storey Sutton office tower

Landmark project to deliver 312 Build to rent and 195 co-living homes
23 hours ago

Building envelope specialist Bailey buys Comar

Specialist now offers complete building envelope solutions
23 hours ago

Subcontractors wanted for work across Wales

Big name buyers at latest Constructionline event: Register now
22 hours ago

Balfour Beatty profit dented by £83m building safety hit

Increased order book at £18bn secures growth over next two years
2 days ago

Expanding utilities specialist Ipsum buys Matrix Power

Power engineering contractor takeover will strengthen offer in North East
2 days ago

Historic scaffolding firm files administration notice

Hertfordshire based Rodells has been trading since 1898
2 days ago

Planning Bill to have “seismic” impact on construction

Building-boosting reforms go before Parliament
3 days ago

Briggs & Forrester hits record revenue and orders

M&E specialist rebounds with strong growth across three divisions
2 days ago

Man Utd confirm plan for £2bn ‘super-tent’ stadium

Club to press ahead with 100,000-seat 'Wembley of the North'
3 days ago

Government spending keeps profits edging-up at Kier

91% of work now with public sector and regulated companies
3 days ago

Costain on track for step change to 5% margin

Alex Vaughan says order book has jumped £1.5bn to £5.4bn
3 days ago

Mace tops February contracts league

Confirmation of £300m London Victoria Street project lifts firm to pole position
3 days ago

Wates raids Laing O’Rourke for new construction operations chief

George Mosey leaves Laing O'Rourke after 16 years
4 days ago

Travis Perkins CEO Pete Redfern steps down due to ill health

Redfern joined builders' merchant last year after 14 years at Taylor Wimpey
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins £61m Liverpool lab scheme

Construction to start this Autumn on latest Knowledge Quarter project
3 days ago

Glencar to build timber-framed office block

Work to start next month on 79,200 sq ft scheme in Maidenhead
4 days ago

Shed specialist Marbank files administration notice

£67m turnover portal-framed building specialist files court notice
4 days ago

Birmingham council submits £1bn Druids Heath plan

High rise estate to be replaced by-3,500 home eco village
4 days ago

Cannabis farm gang posed as utilities contractor

Gang jailed for 28 years after diverting power to more than 100 cannabis farms
6 days ago

Firm fined after workers climb scaffold without ladder

HSE investigation prompted by death on Liverpool site
4 days ago

Clancy renews £250m Southern Water deal

Contractor vows to maximise value for money and minimise disruption
4 days ago

McLaren go-ahead for 314 flats Watford scheme

Police station and magistrates court to be demolished
4 days ago

Former Liverpool mayor charged in building contracts probe

Construction bosses also charged as part of Operation Aloft
7 days ago

Bidding to start for £700m Irish sea interconnector work

Work includes converter stations at Hunterston and Kilroot near Belfast
7 days ago

Muse to redevelop Durham County Hall HQ site

Morgan Sindall regen specialist seals another major development deal
7 days ago

Contractor services